Manufacturers

Listen Anarchist by Chaz Bufe

Listen Anarchist by Chaz Bufe

Mr See Sharpe Press passionately suggests reasons why anarchism has not "caught on" as he believes if should have.

More details


£1.00

Introduction

by Janet Biehl

The republication of Listen, Anarchist! 13 years after its first appearance is a particularly welcome event. In only a few pages Chaz Bufe succeeds in diagnosing many of the ills of North American anarchism, both in ideas and activities. The power of the pamphlet derives not only from the pithiness of its insights and its unpretentious style, but from its clear and forceful exposition and its willingness to speak out against immorality and injustice within the movement.

Lamentably, the intervening years since 1987 have not cured the malaises Bufe diagnosed. On the contrary, they have acquired greater virulence. Fifth Estate, for example, has continued propagating its anti-technological, primitivistic, and mystical doctrines. David Watson (aka George Bradford, among other pseudonyms) has even tried, in Beyond Bookchin, to appropriate the term "social ecology" for these regressive notions, attempting to supplant a body of forward-looking, rational, and humanistic libertarian ideas with his own benighted primitivism.

At about the same time that Watson's essay appeared, an editor of the English magazine Green Anarchist came out in support of the Unabomber, the Oklahoma City bombing, and the Aum Shinrikyo cult, which released sarin nerve gas in the Tokyo subway. (Green Anarchist is an anarcho-primitivist periodical that regards Fifth Estate as one of its precursors.) This appalling development showed, among other things, the merit of Bufe's criticism of primitivism and mysticism: "if anarchists reject rationality and revert to mysticism, it's a safe bet that they too will go goose-stepping off in increasingly authoritarian directions." Only in the fall of 1997, in a discussion of Green Anarchist, did Watson finally begin to retreat from his primitivist views.

In the meantime, Robert C. Black has gone on to celebrate Anarchy After Leftism, in a book whose smokescreen of insult and vitriol hides a basic lack of ideas about what "anarchy after leftism" really represents, apart perhaps from the supremacy of self-interest. In these writings anarchism's longstanding socialist dimension is jettisoned in favor of individual escapades. Black's personal conduct has mirrored his amoral views. In 1996, he acted as a police narcotics informant against Seattle author Jim Hogshire, resulting in a police raid on Hogshire's home. [See the Loompanics Unlimited Fall 1996 Supplement, pp. 12–17 for details; see also the narcing letter from "citizen informant" Bob Black to the Seattle Police Department.]

Many of the ills Bufe documents in Listen, Anarchist! derive ultimately from anarchism's individualistic tendency, whose animating spirit is the 19th-century anarcho-egoist Max Stirner. From the dragon's teeth that Stirner sowed have sprung, most recently, a legion of "fashion" or "life-style" anarchists who appear to be unfamiliar with anarchism's claim to constitute an ethical socialism.

In fact, one of the most disquieting observations that Bufe makes is that some anarchists have reacted to incidents of immorality and even violence with indifference: "Sure Bob Black is a destructive nut,"he quotes one as saying, "but he hasn't attacked us." Similarly, a comrade in the Netherlands —where Black's writings have, astonishingly, gained some popularity—has told me that when he tells Black's local fans of his violent and unethical activities, they respond with equal indifference. Currently in the U.S., despite Black's narcing on Jim Hogshire—a widely known betrayal of anarchist principles (contact Loompanics for details)—at least a few vocal "anarchists" continue to support Black and his brand of amoral egoism.

Such unconcern is a far cry from the left-libertarian ethos that once proclaimed, "An injury to one is an injury to all!" Apathy in the face of immoral and unjust behavior toward one's fellow anarchists, let alone toward one's fellow human beings, reflects a grave breach of the ethical standards with which anarchists have long identified themselves, in contrast to many marxists and, especially, leninists. Ethics lies at the heart of a truly libertarian movement that offers a vision of a cooperative and humane society. An anarchism that dismisses even gross violations of basic ethical standards with an anemic shrug has not only lost its moral high ground as the libertarian alternative to authoritarian or state socialism; it has undermined its claim to represent a movement for basic change, individual as well as social. Instead it has become a pseudo-rebellious conceit, a self-serving gloss, a passing stage of late childhood development, or as Bufe puts it very well, a fashion trend.

The diffusion of such moral indifference among anarchists would transform anarchism itself into something that most of those who once proudly used that label would scarcely recognize. Libertarians today who cherish ideas of a cooperative and just society would do well to express their outrage at immorality and violence in their own milieu as well as in the larger society, reaffirming anarchism's call for ethical renovation. Only then will we have a movement that deserves to gain wider support.

Cart  

No products

£0.00 Shipping
£0.00 Total

Cart Check out

New products

  • The Red Flag of Anarchy
  • An Encyclopedia of Political Record Labels by Josh MacPhee
The Red Flag of Anarchy
A history of Socialism and Anarchism in Sheffield 1874-1900 by Andrew Lee.
Read more
An Encyclopedia of Political Record Labels by Josh MacPhee
 Truly international in scope, over two dozen countries and territories...
Read more
Maximum Rocknroll *410 July 2017
Mexico City’s RIÑA, Iceland’s DAUÐYFLIN, Olympia’s XYLITOL, LIFE FUCKER...
Read more
No Wall They Can Build
A Guide to Borders & Migration Across North America from Crimethinc
Read more
Peter Kropotkin: Anarchism & The State
Three essays presented by Peter Kropotkin
Read more
Organise *88
The Summer 2017 magazine of the Anarchist Federation
Read more
Altercado, ...cancion a los poderes CD
Chilean hardcore politico crust punk
Read more
Agent 86, New Wave Sucks (Early Days Discography) CD
Agent 86's Just Say No, Vietnam Generation and Apartheid American Style...
Read more
Alians, Nielegalni MCD
Polish ska punk crew release a CD single on the Pasazer label
Read more
Andy fiction, The Futures History cd
Uk based politico HC crew from 2006
Read more
@patia No, El Ruido De Antes... Contra Los Opresores De Siempre CD
Venezuelan hardcore politico punk on Skuld Releases
Read more
Bella Fica, Nešahej Mi Na Štěstí CD
Czech female fronted punk
Read more
The Bristles, Union Bashing State CD
4 track MCD from the Swedish politico punx
Read more
Burn at all, A l’abri d’nos conneries CD
"Nice hardcore punk from Brittany. Great killing sound, 12 tracks."
Read more
Calibre 12 ‎– Resistiremos Até Ao Fim CD
Brazilian Hardcore Punk band
Read more
Cards in Spokes, Stix, Nix, His, Pix CD
Allied recordings release another Us melodic punk band.
Read more
Cartouche, Je Trahirai Demain CD
Parisian feminist hardcore punk crew.
Read more
CAST IRON IN "IX" CD
Polish Hardcore
Read more
Cash For Chaos, Stepahead CD
Hardcore Cd
Read more
Fifth Estate, Summer 2017, *398
The latest issue is titled Revolutions, Revolts, Riots and Rebellions.
Read more

» All new products